Dr. Cody McNutt: Why First Baptist Chose Demolition to Preserve Its Mission—Episode 59

In this episode of The Town Square Podcast, co-host Trey Bailey sit down with Dr. Cody McNutt, Senior Pastor of First Baptist Church of Covington, for a candid and compelling conversation about faith, leadership, and bold decision-making. Dr. McNutt opens up about the emotional and strategic journey behind First Baptist’s controversial decision to demolish its historic sanctuary—a space rich in memory but limited in future functionality. He shares how the church’s “Growing Together” campaign emerged not just as a building project but as a vision for deeper community engagement and Gospel-centered impact in a rapidly growing Newton County.

The conversation moves beyond bricks and mortar to tackle bigger questions about the role of the Church in today’s cultural landscape. Dr. McNutt reflects on the challenges of navigating public opinion, preserving sacred traditions, and leading a congregation toward future-forward ministry. He also discusses the church’s 5–10 year plan, their approach to outreach, and how pastors can stay rooted in calling while adapting to change. Whether you’re a person of faith, a community leader, or just someone who cares about the evolving story of Covington, this episode offers wisdom, transparency, and a refreshing look at the “messy middle” of modern church leadership.